ACL repair and the BEAR implant
Reconstruction replaces the torn ACL with a tendon graft. Repair tries to save your own ligament by sewing it back together or back to the bone, sometimes with a scaffold that helps it heal. Repair avoids taking a graft, but in most studies it fails more often than reconstruction, especially in young patients. This page summarizes what the research shows.
What ACL repair means
- Primary repair. The torn ligament is sewn back to its attachment on the thigh bone, often reinforced with a strong suture tape (an "internal brace"). It is only possible when the ligament tears right off the bone (a proximal tear) and the tissue is good quality.
- Bridge-enhanced ACL restoration (BEAR). A sponge-like scaffold made of protein is placed between the torn ends, filled with your own blood, and held with sutures. It is meant to help a tear in the middle of the ligament heal. The FDA cleared the BEAR implant in 2020 for skeletally mature patients at least 14 years old with a complete tear, a stump of ligament still attached to the shin bone, and surgery within 50 days of injury.1
How often does it fail?
When repair was compared directly with reconstruction, repair carried about 1.6 times the risk of failure and of revision surgery.2 Results vary a lot by technique: one dynamic repair device had failure rates of about 35% at 5 years.2
Age is the biggest factor. In patients 21 and younger, repair had up to six times the risk of revision compared with reconstruction, while in adults over 21 there was no significant difference.3 Timing matters too. Repairs done within 3 weeks of injury had failure rates similar to reconstruction, while those done later failed more often.4
What the trials show
In the BEAR II randomized trial, 100 patients with a median age of 17 had either BEAR or autograft reconstruction.5,7 At 2 years, patient-reported function and knee laxity were not inferior to reconstruction,5 and BEAR patients had better hamstring strength because no tendon was taken.1 They also felt more psychologically ready to return to sport at 6 months.7 But 14% of BEAR patients needed a revision, compared with 6% after reconstruction.5 The failure rate was highest in the youngest patients.6
What predicts BEAR failure
- Younger age. The odds of revision dropped by about 32% for each year older the patient was.6
- Steeper tibial slope. The odds rose by about 28% for each degree of extra backward slope of the shin bone.6
- A contact injury at the time of the tear was also linked to a higher risk.6
- Sex, activity level, knee hyperextension, and meniscus tears did not predict failure.6
Repair or reconstruction?
Repair has real advantages: no graft is taken, hamstring strength is better preserved, and some patients feel their knee is more natural. The trade-off is a higher chance of needing a second operation, which is largest in teenagers and young athletes in pivoting sports, the group that tears the ACL most often.
For most patients, reconstruction remains the most reliable option. Repair may be reasonable for select patients: older, lower-risk patients with a recent tear and good-quality tissue, who understand the higher revision risk. We will go over your age, sport, tear pattern, and goals to decide together.
References
- 1Shah AK, Neijna AG, Retzky JS, Gomoll AH, Strickland SM. Indications, techniques, and outcomes of bridge-enhanced ACL restoration (BEAR). Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2025;18(4):140–148. Link →
- 2Kunze KN, Pareek A, Nwachukwu BU, et al. Clinical results of primary repair versus reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament: a systematic review and meta-analysis of contemporary trials. Orthop J Sports Med. 2024;12(6). Link →
- 3Rilk S, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament primary repair revision rates are increased in skeletally mature patients under the age of 21 compared to reconstruction, while adults (>21 years) show no significant difference: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2025;33(1):29–58. Link →
- 4Utoyo GA, et al. Arthroscopic repair for acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture results in higher failure rates and greater residual knee laxity compared to reconstruction if performed more than 3 weeks after injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2026. Link →
- 5Murray MM, Fleming BC, Badger GJ, et al. Bridge-enhanced anterior cruciate ligament repair is not inferior to autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction at 2 years: results of a prospective randomized clinical trial. Am J Sports Med. 2020;48(6):1305–1315. Link →
- 6Sanborn RM, Badger GJ, Fleming BC, et al. Preoperative risk factors for subsequent ipsilateral ACL revision surgery after an ACL restoration procedure. Am J Sports Med. 2023. Link →
- 7Sanborn RM, Badger GJ, et al. Psychological readiness to return to sport at 6 months is higher after bridge-enhanced ACL restoration than autograft ACL reconstruction: results of a prospective randomized clinical trial. Orthop J Sports Med. 2022;10(2). Link →
This page summarizes published research for patient education. Study results describe groups of patients and may not apply to you. It is not a substitute for an evaluation and a discussion of your own knee.