Clavicle fracture: plate or sling?
Most collarbone fractures heal well in a sling. When the fracture is completely displaced, meaning the broken ends no longer touch, or the bone is shortened, the picture changes. This page summarizes what randomized trials show about healing, nonunion, malunion, strength, and the trade-offs of surgery for these displaced midshaft fractures.
How the two approaches compare
Will the bone heal?
A nonunion means the bone never knits together. It usually causes ongoing pain, clicking, and weakness, and is treated with surgery and often a bone graft.
Older studies reported very few nonunions with a sling, but they included children and minimally displaced fractures that heal easily. In adults with completely displaced fractures, the nonunion rate is much higher.1,5 Complete displacement, comminution (several fragments), and smoking all raise the risk.6
Healing in the wrong position
A malunion means the bone heals, but shortened or angled. Many malunions cause no problems. A symptomatic malunion causes a drooping shoulder, pain with overhead use, fatigue, a visible bump, or discomfort from straps and backpacks.
In the landmark Canadian trial, more displacement on the X-ray was linked to worse arm function in patients treated in a sling.1
How much strength comes back?
The clavicle acts as a strut that holds the shoulder out from the body. When it heals shortened, the shoulder muscles work at a disadvantage. In a study that measured strength years after sling treatment of displaced fractures, the injured shoulder was weaker than the uninjured one:7
Strength after sling treatment (% of uninjured side)
Endurance, or how long you can keep using the arm, was affected most. Restoring the length and alignment of the clavicle with surgery is meant to prevent these deficits.1
What to know about plate fixation
- Plate irritation. The plate sits just under the skin, so some people feel it with backpack or seatbelt straps. Implant-related problems are the most common complication.4
- Plate removal. Some patients choose to have the plate removed after the bone has healed. When plate removal is counted, the overall rate of a second operation was similar after surgery (17.6%) and after sling treatment (16.6%).3
- Numbness below the incision from small skin nerves, which usually improves over time.
- Infection and the general risks of anesthesia, which are uncommon.
Choosing the right treatment
Most clavicle fractures do well without surgery. We generally recommend plate fixation for:
- Completely displaced fractures where the bone ends don't touch, or that are significantly shortened.
- Active patients, athletes, and manual workers who need overhead strength and endurance, or want a faster return to work and sport.
- Skin at risk from a sharp bone end, open fractures, or injuries to nearby nerves or blood vessels.
- Multiple injuries such as a floating shoulder or fractures in both arms.
For minimally displaced fractures, or patients who prefer to avoid surgery, a sling with close X-ray follow-up is a good choice. If the bone doesn't heal, surgery can still be done later.
References
- 1Canadian Orthopaedic Trauma Society. Nonoperative treatment compared with plate fixation of displaced midshaft clavicular fractures: a multicenter, randomized clinical trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(1):1–10. Link →
- 2McKee RC, Whelan DB, Schemitsch EH, McKee MD. Operative versus nonoperative care of displaced midshaft clavicular fractures: a meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2012;94(8):675–684. Link →
- 3Woltz S, Krijnen P, Schipper IB. Plate fixation versus nonoperative treatment for displaced midshaft clavicular fractures: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017;99(12):1051–1057. Link →
- 4Wijdicks FJ, Van der Meijden OA, Millett PJ, et al. Systematic review of the complications of plate fixation of clavicle fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2012. Link →
- 5Zlowodzki M, Zelle BA, Cole PA, et al. Treatment of acute midshaft clavicle fractures: systematic review of 2144 fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2005;19(7):504–507. Link →
- 6Murray IR, Foster CJ, Eros A, Robinson CM. Risk factors for nonunion after nonoperative treatment of displaced midshaft fractures of the clavicle. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2013;95(13):1153–1158. Link →
- 7McKee MD, Pedersen EM, Jones C, et al. Deficits following nonoperative treatment of displaced midshaft clavicular fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2006;88(1):35–40. Link →
This page summarizes published research for patient education. Study results describe groups of patients and may not apply to you. It is not a substitute for an evaluation and a discussion of your own injury.