← Back to discoid meniscus tear
Discoid meniscus · Evidence review

Saucerization for discoid meniscus: what to expect

Saucerization trims the thick center of a discoid meniscus to leave a normal C-shaped meniscus, keeping a healthy rim at the edge. If that rim is loose or torn, it is repaired at the same time. In the past, the whole discoid meniscus was often removed. This page summarizes what the research shows about results after saucerization, how often more surgery is needed, and the long-term outlook.

Why preserve it

Saucerization vs removing the meniscus

Removing the whole meniscus leaves the outer side of the knee without its cushion. Long-term studies show better patient-reported results after saucerization than after total meniscectomy, even though the two look similar in the first few years.1

  • Osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the thigh bone after surgery
  • Saucerization + repair
  • 4%
  • Subtotal meniscectomy
  • 27%
  • Children and adolescents with discoid tears.2

OCD is a problem with the bone and cartilage of the thigh bone on the outer side of the knee. It was much more common when most of the meniscus was removed.2 The goal of saucerization is to leave a stable rim that can still cushion the joint.

Clinical results

How children and teens do

72.9 → 90.5
Average knee function score (Lysholm, out of 100) before and about 10 years after rim-preserving saucerization in children.3
97%
Of children and teens returned to full activity after meniscus-preserving surgery.4
90.6%
Did not need further surgery at 10 years after limited saucerization.5

Across studies of children, saucerization alone and saucerization with repair both led to large improvements in pain and function.6 In a 2025 study followed for an average of 10.5 years, only 3.6% of children had excellent or good scores before surgery, compared with 64.2% afterward.3

More surgery

How often is a second operation needed?

7.3%
Reoperation after saucerization alone in a 2026 review of pediatric studies.6
8.9%
Reoperation after saucerization with repair.6
8.3%
Reoperation over a median of 8 years in a long-term pediatric study.4

Most studies report low reoperation rates, but they vary a lot. Some report retear rates as high as 24% and reoperation rates as high as 37%.7 A discoid meniscus is abnormal tissue, and the rim that is left can tear again, especially in active kids who return to cutting and jumping sports. A new tear can usually be treated with another arthroscopy.

Repair

Does adding a repair help?

A symptomatic discoid meniscus in a child is often unstable at the rim. When the rim is loose, it is sewn back to the capsule so it stays in place. Reviews have found that adding a repair does not clearly improve scores over saucerization alone,1,6 but the knees that need repair usually have more complex tears to begin with.6 The decision to repair is made during surgery, based on how stable the rim is and the pattern of the tear.6

Long-term outlook

What happens over time

  • Arthritis risk rises with time. The longer patients are followed after any discoid surgery, the more arthritis is seen on X-ray.8 Keeping as much meniscus as possible is the best way to reduce that risk.
  • OCD can develop on the outer thigh bone after surgery. In the 10-year study, two children developed it, and both healed without more surgery.3
  • Follow-up matters. Children who have new pain, swelling, or catching after saucerization should be checked for a new tear, and the other knee is worth examining, since discoid menisci often occur on both sides.

References

  1. 1Smuin DM, Swenson RD, Dhawan A. Saucerization versus complete resection of a symptomatic discoid lateral meniscus at short- and long-term follow-up: a systematic review. Arthroscopy. 2017;33(9):1733–1742. Link →
  2. 2Combined meniscal saucerization and repair versus subtotal meniscectomy for symptomatic discoid lateral meniscal tears in children and adolescents. Orthop J Sports Med. 2025. Link →
  3. 3Obro RB, Rassi J, Flumian C, Sales de Gauzy J, Accadbled F. Arthroscopic management of discoid lateral meniscus in children: 5-year minimum follow-up clinical outcome. J Child Orthop. 2025. Link →
  4. 4Said M, Henick SM, Samuel Z, et al. Favorable long-term outcomes following arthroscopic preservation surgery for pediatric and adolescent discoid lateral meniscus. J Pediatr Orthop. 2026;46(9):e814–e820. Link →
  5. 5Midterm to long-term follow-up after limited saucerization of a discoid lateral meniscus: radiological and functional outcomes with age-dependent variations. Orthop J Sports Med. 2025. Link →
  6. 6Hartman et al. Outcomes of saucerization with or without repair for symptomatic discoid lateral meniscus in pediatric patients: a systematic review. Arthroscopy. 2026. Link →
  7. 7Vivekanantha P, Thomas R, Kaplan G, et al. Surgical management of the discoid lateral meniscus: a systematic review of outcomes. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2025;18(11):513–535. Link →
  8. 8Lee YS, Teo SH, Ahn JH, Lee OS, Lee SH, Lee JH. Systematic review of the long-term surgical outcomes of discoid lateral meniscus. Arthroscopy. 2017;33(10):1884–1895. Link →

This page summarizes published research for patient education. Study results describe groups of patients and may not apply to your child. It is not a substitute for an evaluation and a discussion of your own knee.

Kevin Jiang, MD
Orthopaedic Surgery · Sports Medicine
English · Mandarin · Spanish
Accepting new patients
Locations
72-06 Northern Blvd, 2nd Fl
Jackson Heights, NY 11372

2825 Jackson Ave
Long Island City, NY 11101

(866) 670-6824
Fax: (718) 533-1770
Where surgery happens
NewYork-Presbyterian Queens
56-45 Main Street, 4th Fl South
Flushing, NY 11355
(718) 670-2558
Hospital affiliations: NewYork-Presbyterian Queens; NewYork-Presbyterian / Columbia University Irving Medical Center; Hospital for Special Surgery (Affiliate Medical Staff). Institutional names denote affiliation, not endorsement.
This site is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Use of this site does not create a doctor-patient relationship. For emergencies call 911.
© 2026 Kevin Jiang, MD