Humerus shaft fracture: brace or surgery?
Most breaks in the middle of the upper arm bone can heal in a functional brace, a snug plastic sleeve that holds the bone while you keep using the arm. Surgery holds the bone with a plate and screws or a rod. Both approaches can give good results. The differences are in how fast you recover, how often the bone fails to heal, and the risks of surgery. This page summarizes what the research shows.
How the two approaches compare
What the FISH trial showed
The FISH randomized trial compared plate fixation with bracing for displaced shaft fractures in adults.1 At 12 months, arm function scores were not significantly different between the groups.1 Surgery gave a faster and more predictable recovery in the first months,1 and about 1 in 6 braced patients needed surgery later because the bone was not healing.2
The bar chart shows the key finding. Patients whose fracture healed in a brace did as well as those who had surgery at the start. Patients who started in a brace but needed surgery later because the bone didn't heal had worse function at 2 years.2 Results were similar at 5 years.6
Will the bone heal?
A nonunion means the bone hasn't healed after about 6 months. It usually needs surgery, often with a bone graft. Operative treatment roughly halves the risk of nonunion.5 Because a nonunion leads to more surgery, overall reintervention was also higher with bracing (14.3% vs 8.9%).4
What to know about fixation
- Nerve injury. The radial nerve, which lifts the wrist and fingers, wraps around the middle of the arm bone. Surgery carries about a 3% risk of injuring it,3 though most cases recover. Permanent nerve palsy was equally rare with either treatment.4
- Infection. About 3–4% after surgery, and deep infection is more common than with a brace.3,5
- Healing problems can still happen after surgery, though less often than with a brace.5
Who benefits from surgery
A brace is a good choice for many people, especially if you are willing to wear it for several months and accept a somewhat higher chance of needing surgery later. We generally favor surgery for:
- Patients who want a faster, more predictable recovery, such as athletes and people who need to return to work quickly.
- Fractures that can’t be held well in a brace, or that are clearly not healing on X-ray after several weeks.
- Open fractures, injuries to the blood vessels, or a nerve palsy that develops after the fracture is set.
- Multiple injuries, such as fractures in both arms or the leg, where using crutches or the other arm depends on the broken arm.
References
- 1Rämö L, Sumrein BO, Lepola V, et al. Effect of surgery vs functional bracing on functional outcome among patients with closed displaced humeral shaft fractures: the FISH randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2020;323(18):1792–1801. Link →
- 2Rämö L, Paavola M, Sumrein BO, et al. Outcomes with surgery vs functional bracing for patients with closed, displaced humeral shaft fractures and the need for secondary surgery: a prespecified secondary analysis of the FISH randomized clinical trial. JAMA Surg. 2021;156(6). Link →
- 3Sargeant HW, Farrow L, Barker S, Kumar K. Operative versus non-operative treatment of humeral shaft fractures: a systematic review. Shoulder Elbow. 2020. Link →
- 4Conservative vs. operative treatment for humeral shaft fractures: a meta-analysis and systematic review of randomized clinical trials and observational studies. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2020. Link →
- 5Operative versus nonoperative treatment of humeral shaft fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2020. Link →
- 6Rämö L, Ibounig T, Sumrein BO, et al. Five-year follow-up of surgery vs functional bracing for closed displaced humeral shaft fractures. JAMA. 2024;331(13):1149–1151. Link →
- 7Humeral shaft fractures (review). EFORT Open Rev. 2021;6(1). Link →
- 8Orapiriyakul W, Apivatthakakul V, Theppariyapol B, Apivatthakakul T. Humerus shaft fractures, approaches and management. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2023;43:102230. Link →
This page summarizes published research for patient education. Study results describe groups of patients and may not apply to you. It is not a substitute for an evaluation and a discussion of your own injury.